by In Vino Rimoribis It has become blatantly apparent that the European Commission’s communication strategy over TTIP has become shambolic. A situation has developed where NGOs have built a powerful alliance and persuaded a majority of the public that TTIP is bad for the EU.
The current impasse has its roots in the early days of the TTIP negotiations. At the outset, the Commission was acutely aware that to deliver an agreement with the USA, communication would be vital. it was supposed to be a pan-Commission priority with Directorate-General (DG) Trade working with other DGs, especially with DG Communication. Instead, DG Trade ‘captured’ the communication strategy and implicitly excluded all others.
The major problem was that an intended open and transparent process was run by a DG whose culture was based on discretion and legal process. It shunned the Commission’s own in-house communication experts and failed to hire external advisers well-versed in selling messages.
By its very nature, DG Trade is used to dealing with client confidentiality, commercial sensitivities, pricing and cost structures etc. etc. It is structurally unsuited to dealing with the sophisticated and fast acting communication strategists of TTIPs opponents. Yet, trying to keep the negotiating strategy secret, the Commission has shot itself in the foot. The EU public should have been informed of every negotiating nuance and move before they happened.
To believe that the US Government and its negotiating team did not know of every last detail of the Commission’s strategies and tactics would be naive in the extreme. The USA’s sophisticated listening and monitoring operations would have picked up every last detail about TTIP from across the EU and what was going on in Brussels.
Even the ongoing row about ISDS (Investor-State dispute settlement) has been handled badly. The EU has about ninety free trade agreements where ISDS is already part of each agreement. This has caused no problems. The Commission should have been far more open about ISDS as it has allowed TTIPs opponents to characterise ISDS as a back-door deal for proponents of privatisation.
The Commission needs to transform its TTIP communication strategy by being utterly transparent in its future communication strategy, but it has now left itself an enormous uphill task.