Public Affairs Networking
Italy’s Justice System in Shambles According to Reports

According to a recent report by the OECD, the Italian judicial system is in dire straits and on the brink of a total collapse. As a matter of fact, it is said that it currently takes 1,000 days for cases to make it to the highest court in the land. These delays have been decried by many in the European Union, and various human rights groups as well.

Judicial System in Shambles

Giuseppe Nicoletti, who works as an executive member of the OECD, says Italy is dead last in many categories. Most notably, when it comes to judgments. In all stages, the duration times are significantly higher in the country than anywhere else in the Union. Nicoletti mentioned that in Switzerland, cases typically take 400 days to get through all stages of judgments compared to the 1,000 days it takes in Italy.

As a matter of fact, among all OECD countries, Italy came last when it came to duration, beating Russia and South Africa. It has been estimated that the average cases take about 454 days to get through the first instance court in Italy. In comparison, the duration time is 240 days in the rest of the OECD countries on average.

System is Plagued with Corruption

One of the areas where the Italian criminal justice system is severely crippled is when confronting white collar criminals. The time it takes for criminals to be prosecuted and sentenced is so long that statutes of limitations can sometimes override the sentence. In Italy, statutes of limitations are calculated from the time the crime was allegedly committed, not discovered. This means that a lengthy investigation coupled with the length of judgment allows many to get away scot-free.

What the Solution?

Many have argued that lack of formation at the grassroots level is one of the biggest issues. The country currently has a big shortage in criminal behaviorists with masters in criminal justice. This leads to higher risk of recidivism, which further clogs the judicial system. Many officials have pushed more people to enrol in online masters in criminal justice programs from institutions like the University of Cincinnati to fill the ranks.

The impact of Italy’s poor judicial system has far reaching consequences, principally on the country’s economy. The country currently has one of the lowest foreign investment rates in the region, which can be attributed largely to a lack of confidence in the country’s judicial system. Nicoletti also noted that lawyers in the country are profiting from the lengthy judgments because of their remuneration schemes.

To counter the effects of the sluggish system, all levels of governments will have to be involved and work together to raise the number of magistrates and consider reversing the trend of lawyers dragging cases to get higher remuneration. Many in office have tried to propose new changes, but they are being met with opposition from corrupt officials who are working out of self-interest. While

Nicoletti says that he has faith in the recent set of reforms that were implemented, he would still like to see them being monitored better to make sure that they eventually bear fruit.

 

Comments
No comments yet
Submit a comment

Policy and networking for the digital age
Policy Review TV Neil Stewart Associates
© Policy Review | Policy and networking for the digital age 2026 | Log-in | Proudly powered by WordPress
Policy Review EU is part of the NSA & Policy Review Publishing Network